Tall palm trees in front of Spanish colonial buildings in St. Augustine, Florida

Dining in St. Augustine, Florida: America’s Oldest City

Tall palm trees in front of Spanish colonial buildings in St. Augustine, Florida

Dining in St. Augustine, Florida: America’s Oldest City

When searching for an ideal vacation destination, many travelers choose St. Augustine, Florida, for its colorful past and fabulous food.

When hunting for the ideal vacation destination, many people turn to America’s oldest city. Drenched in natural beauty and Spanish colonial charm, St. Augustine, on Florida’s northeast coast, features beautiful beaches, a colorful past, and fabulous food. A melting pot of Spanish, Greek, Cuban, Italian, African, and Native American flavors influence the local cuisine, and chefs harvest the Atlantic Ocean and Florida’s fertile farmlands for fresh, local ingredients. Discover the best bites in downtown St. Augustine, from pizza with the kids to continental cuisine with a date.

Casual Get Together: The Ice Plant

The Ice Plant serves up delicious seafood and farm-to-table fare for lunch, dinner, and weekend brunch. Formerly a working ice plant, the refurbished 90-year old building offers a trendy, old-school feel with design details like brick and wood accents, soaring ceilings, exposed beams, and polished wood floors. Sporting vintage-style suspenders and colorful head scarves, even the bartenders become part of the atmosphere. Creative cocktails feature fresh-pressed juices, special syrups, a variety of bitters, and different shapes of ice, including spheres, long rocks, and pebbles.

Plates of fresh food with wine glasses on a table in a restaurant in St. Augustine, Florida
Source: Shutterstock

Fine Dining and Romance: La Pentola

In St. Augustine, locals in love turn to La Pentola for a romantic dining experience. The building features picturesque Spanish colonial architecture outside, while couples soak up warm, Old World ambience inside. Details like a cozy fireplace, colorful artwork, decorative wrought-iron chairs, and crisp white linens set the stage for an enchanting evening. Delicious continental cuisine features menu options like lobster ravioli, duck a l’orange, and chicken Marsala. An extensive wine list provides a pairing for every dish.

Family Time: Pizzalley’s on St. George

A charming entrance adorned with string lights and flowering plants isn’t the only thing that beckons family diners to Pizzalley’s on St. George. This cozy establishment serves up some of the best pizza in town with fresh toppings, gooey cheese, and a slightly crunchy crust. From comfy indoor booths to outdoor tables in the courtyard, the restaurant provides a great family atmosphere for dining on generous pizza slices or whole Italian pies. In addition to standard cheese, sausage, and pepperoni, the menu includes unique pizzas like the Chicken Tropical with pineapple, feta, and almonds. For more refined Italian dining, try The Chianti Room located in the back of the building.

Dinner with the Guys (or Girls): Prohibition Kitchen

With the clandestine vibe of an old-time speakeasy, Prohibition Kitchen is the perfect option for dinner with the guys or the girls. Features like reclaimed wood, pressed-tin ceilings, polished concrete flooring, and period antiques ooze authenticity while diners enjoy live music from comfortable booths and tables. From small plates like crawfish pot pie and crispy chicken wings to more substantial fare like craft burgers and barbecued chicken, there’s something for every appetite. Despite the name, adult beverage options include beer, hard cider, wine, and cocktails.

Fresh lettuce and cherry tomatoes with ice cubes on a table in St. Augustine, Florida
Source: Shutterstock

Saturday Morning Breakfast: Georgie’s Diner

Nothing kicks off the weekend like a hearty breakfast, especially when someone else cooks. Featuring colorful 1950s-style décor in the form of cherry-red stools and checkered tile flooring, Georgie’s Diner offers a bright, nostalgic atmosphere and friendly service. Heaping plates of pancakes, waffles, and bacon and eggs satisfy even the hungriest patrons, and fresh-squeezed orange juice adds a little something extra-special to the meal.

Additional Restaurant Recommendations

For some of the best eats in the city, try these popular eateries that add to the dining experience by offering features with extra appeal:

  • Outdoor Dining: Harry’s Seafood, Bar & Grille offers casual dining in an outdoor courtyard with nightly live music.
  • Vegan Food: Present Moment Cafe takes a holistic approach to food with a vegan, raw, and gluten-free menu.
  • Food Truck: Crave is a food truck that puts a delicious health-conscious twist on salads, wraps, and smoothies.
  • Ocean Views: Located between St. Augustine and Ponte Vedra, Cap’s on the Water is an oyster bar and seafood restaurant situated right on the Atlantic.

With so many flavorful dining options available in St. Augustine, the only challenge is narrowing down the list of possibilities. Share your favorite dining experiences with us on Twitter.

Travel